The New Face of Defense Appeals During Price v. Clark Limbo?

When Gov. Haley Barbour petitioned the Mississippi Supreme Court for leave to file an amicus brief in Price v. Clark, a rare procedural win for plaintiffs in the post-tort reform era, he made no bones about his motivations. The brief is, in whole, a policy argument. There's not a drop of legal analysis to it. Barbour spent every ounce of effort illustrating a slippery slope down which, he argued, the Court risked rolling all the "hard work" of tort reform.

Whether that carries in any weight at the Court is, for the moment, anybody's guess. According to the Court's docket, the justices haven't yet ruled on Barbour's motion for permission to have his brief considered, and they probably won't tip their hand until they're ready to rule one way or another on the motion for rehearing.

But in the meantime, Barbour's strategy appears to have gained a following.

Sherwin-Williams was found liable in Jefferson County Circuit Court in July for injuries to a child, and like Barbour's effort in Price, every indication is that the paint manufacturer is preparing to appeal the jury's $7 million judgment by flying the tort-reform flag, applicable law be damned. The appeal hasn't been filed yet, but the company and its allies already are harping about the Court's obligation to "do the right thing," lest the Court risk damage to "the repairs to their reputation that they have made with the tort reforms."

Frankly, it reads more like message board fodder than an appellate strategy.

But that may be the point. The Court's decision in Price, for those who have read it, is hardly a legal stretch. The majority opinion drew full concurrence from all but one member of the Court, and even that justice dissented only in part. Legally speaking, the governor doesn't have much of a leg to stand on. The most he can do is to go back to his 2004 song and dance about "lawsuit abuse" and hope for the best.

It's worked once before (albeit in another branch of government), and until the men and women in black give it a thumbs-down, Sherwin-Williams is banking on it working again.

 Digg 

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this entry.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this entry.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name (required)

 Email (will not be published) (required)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.